Winnable?
A report from two analysts outlines results that are a little surprising. They see strong, tangible evidence that significant progress is being made towards securing a peaceful Iraq - or at least reducing the violence enough for normal life to resume. This report joins a growing body of evidence that the Iraq war might, just might, actually not be total disaster. And the surge might be working. I'm not sure if it's "winnable", since I think we might have already left that one behind, but if we can leave Iraq retreating from a position of strength and having laid a legitimate path towards peace for the Iraqis to follow, then that is certainly not the abject failure that some Democrats are crowing about on the Hill.
While I certainly don't fully agree with the views of the authors on other topics (particularly Mr. Pollack), this view on the surge has been reported enough that it deserves some consideration. General Petraeus, whatever his personal views may be, seems to have a realistic grasp on how to handle a counter-insurgency operation, and the managerial skills to carry it out. Of course, the obstacles remain enormous, and it's far too early to predict the outcome. I certainly hope it works out well....although I would hate to have this emerge as a victory for Bush. In my view, if we have successes in Iraq, they will arrive despite his leadership, not because of it.
A report from two analysts outlines results that are a little surprising. They see strong, tangible evidence that significant progress is being made towards securing a peaceful Iraq - or at least reducing the violence enough for normal life to resume. This report joins a growing body of evidence that the Iraq war might, just might, actually not be total disaster. And the surge might be working. I'm not sure if it's "winnable", since I think we might have already left that one behind, but if we can leave Iraq retreating from a position of strength and having laid a legitimate path towards peace for the Iraqis to follow, then that is certainly not the abject failure that some Democrats are crowing about on the Hill.
While I certainly don't fully agree with the views of the authors on other topics (particularly Mr. Pollack), this view on the surge has been reported enough that it deserves some consideration. General Petraeus, whatever his personal views may be, seems to have a realistic grasp on how to handle a counter-insurgency operation, and the managerial skills to carry it out. Of course, the obstacles remain enormous, and it's far too early to predict the outcome. I certainly hope it works out well....although I would hate to have this emerge as a victory for Bush. In my view, if we have successes in Iraq, they will arrive despite his leadership, not because of it.
Labels: Politics
